Monday, May 3, 2010

J Crew v. Target: The Liberty Peacock Print Swimsuit Challenge

J Crew and Target both offer a peacock-fabric swimsuit this season.

The J Crew, in the original Liberty print, is to the right and costs $125.

The Target, in a reimagined Liberty print (dare I say a Liberty *inspired* print) is below, and costs about $19.99.



To my mind, the Target/Liberty prints look fine when clustered together, but when compared with the original, there's no contest.

Which one do you think is better for the beach this summer?

8 comments:

Belle de Ville said...

Oh God...is it bathing suit time already...

La Belette Rouge said...

I was hoping to like the Target one better. It didn't turn out that way. I don't like all the bunched up fabric. And Jcrew's print is better too.

materfamilias said...

While the second print is pretty enough, and I like that ruching at the bodice, the first suit is a more interesting colour and I do like its print better.

Maggie May said...

Definitely the first. The lines are gorgeous.

Liberty London Girl said...

The Target one is a very clever cut, chosen to flatter the majority of its customers who have as much chance of fitting into that J Crew suit as I do (that'll be zero). And I like how they used the Ianthe print as a springboard for a newly evolved print. For me, it's everything that a diffusion range should be, a homage without pissing off the full price paying customers. LLGxx

Dash said...

No, absolutely no comparison, I must admit I don't like the Target one at all.

When you have a mo, could you pop over to mine, I have something for you.
XX

Angie Muresan said...

I agree with you, but I don't like bathing suits in a print of any kind. Mine's are either black, white or red, and will continue to be so, since I find solid colors definitely classier and more slimming.

Pamela Terry and Edward said...

Methinks I'd rather go to London.